
10 Oct 2018
An Introduction to Economic Risks by FinTech Companies
As financial technology (better known as FinTech) companies become more popular, it is important to shed light on potential threats to financial stability and how we can start to overcome those. After all, it is financial, and at times, personal data is at stake, much of which is connected to banks and other financial institutions, making it more sensitive and therefore more at risk of theft.
In the advent of the Open Banking era, data protection between FinTech companies and financial institutions should be a priority. And yet, with many FinTech companies still classified as start-ups, we must also understand the fact that cybersecurity is not an easy thing to manage.
The Financial Stability Board has had the same thoughts and considerations that they published into a 2017 report about FinTech implications on economic financial stability. This document and many other reports led to the creation of new regulatory frameworks that are aimed at keeping the market open and competitive (in line with all the positive things FinTech companies bring to our economy), while decreasing the risks associated with FinTech's.
We have spoken a lot about the regulations and the positive aspects of FinTech and Open Banking, but we have not spoken about the challenges and risks. In this post, we outline them and make some suggestions to improve the landscape.
What is a FinTech Company?
Before we get started, it is important to outline what we mean by FinTech company here. We have spoken a lot about FinTech's without ever clearly defining them. The Financial Stability Board defines them as:
“technology-enabled innovation in the financial services that could result in new business models, applications, processes or products with an associated material effect on the provision of financial services.”
FinTech is clearly a broad term that can be used to describe a wide range of innovative technologies, so it is sometimes useful to further define them by the economic functions they provide. And so RegTech, InsurTech and SupTech was born. We’ll leave explanations of these for another day.
FinTech services can be classified into major industry sectors and covers a wide range of activities including, but not limited to:
- financing;
- payment and infrastructure;
- operations and risk management;
- data security and monetization and
- customer interface.
Figure 1: Stylised classification of selected FinTech innovations by economic function.
Economic Drivers of FinTech
FinTech companies are a cause of the current economic climate, changing regulation, shifting consumer perspectives and evolving technology. There are three areas that we can break these down into.
Supply Factors
Advances in computing power have allowed innovation in areas such as file sharing, cloud computing, data storage and more. Online connectivity in this way has reduced some transaction costs and disrupted some traditional models which have led to credit innovations.
Look at the FinTech peer-to-peer (P2P) loan provider Zopa, which uses internet technology to cut out banks entirely. And because it automates a lot more than traditional credit institutions, Zopa can provide a far more competitive pricing and offer a more convenient and quicker service to customers.
Platform-based business models are also more able to scale because they use digital identification and digital contracts to standardize online workflows. And because they don’t manage a large number of physical branches with costly IT networks and staffing, they are able to avoid the higher capital and liquidity requirements of traditional institutions.
Finally, because of decisions made in the aftermath of the last financial crisis, services such as micro-lending have been minimised in financial institutions but can be made available to the public by FinTech companies.
Demand Factors
The technological innovations around real-time transacting are placing a higher demand on financial services to follow suit. People want what they want, conveniently, fast and with a good user-friendly experience. As expectations change, younger generations such as “millennials” and “digital natives” have optimal buy-in to FinTech services.
In addition to this, consumers are less trustworthy of banks since the last financial crisis despite the FSCS protecting up to £85,000 of any savings held in any official UK financial institution. There may be more of a general perception that FinTech companies are more trustworthy and socially responsible, especially in areas such as P2P services. This growing faith, alongside a growing demand for ease of application and optimal user experience, may be why investors are keen to use FinTech companies to diversify their portfolios.
In the case of FinTech P2P lending, the higher demand for investors lending on FinTech platforms results in borrowers who are more attracted to use the technology.
We should also bear in mind that FinTech’s service the economy on a greater scale than just those individuals that are digitally advanced and require ease of applications and transactions. These technologies are empowering the "under-banked" and socially vulnerable groups by giving them equal access to various benefits and opportunities, across the globe. Through digital means, residents in far flung areas can receive financial services that were once unattainable to them, such as getting remittances and small loans.
Micro-financial Risks
Micro-financial risks are defined as risks that have more effect on the financial institution or firm itself. Some of these risks could include credit, liquidity, market and pricing, operational, compliance and legal and strategic risks.
Financial Sources
These are the micro-financial risks that relate to financial dealings.
- Maturity mismatch: when a loan is extended for a longer period than the financing is contracted for, rollover risk is created. Systemic impacts could arise if the sector provides critical functions or services.
- Liquidity mismatch: when assets and liabilities have different liquidity characteristics, resulting in “run risk” and the need to liquidate quickly, thereby disrupting markets.
- Leverage: higher leverage implies less equity to absorb losses – an example would be market and credit risks. This could expose counter-parties to losses.
Operational Sources
These are the micro-financial risks that relate to operational dealings.
Governance / Process Control
Poor process control can lead to increased risk of direct disruption in providing financial services or critical infrastructure.
Cyber-Risks
FinTech companies have the potential to increase the attack vendors of the entire economy because the more systems that are connected, the more vulnerabilities there will be for a cyber-criminal to exploit.
A good example of this is the big story of the $81 million bank heist in Bangladesh that used a vulnerability in a third-party technology provider (SWIFT).
As every info security expert knows, the more systems are connected together, the more vectors there are for cyber-attack. However, FinTech’s cannot be grouped into any one particular category and therefore, it should really be individual to each FinTech’s environment although some also follow a self-regulatory framework.
Hiring a good risk manager and IT Security team will be vital in ensuring that the complex and growing list of attack vectors are mitigated.
Third-Party Reliance
An increased reliance on third-party services can create systemic risks too and not just for cyber-risk reasons. FinTech services could be provided to a financial institution and in the event that the cloud computing company (for example) is being used, and later has operational downturn or unexpectedly closes down, the financial institution is affected.
It could be the case that these third-party services are not even heavily involved in the financial industry, such as a telecommunications company. But this does not downplay the risk.
Regulation
Why am I putting regulation down as a risk? The rapid rise of FinTech companies has also meant that the industry is largely unregulated. The reason for this is that rapid developments in technology and innovation are not covered in existing banking regulation. Regulatory frameworks are catching up but, in the meantime, the landscape is uncertain.
Regulations such as GDPR and PSD2 set out requirements for protecting data and securing infrastructures. If these regulations are not followed, there isn’t just a risk of cyber-attack but a risk of being caught, fined and losing brand reputation all in one sweep. This helps to encourage FinTech’s to hold themselves to higher standards and will help the industry to grow.
Some regulations to look out for are:
Financial Market Infrastructures
Financial market structures are also a business risk because they are vulnerable to their own external factors and big changes can impact a business and its profits. If the impact is large enough, it could mean closure and therefore a much wider impact to critical infrastructure.
Macro-Financial Risks
If micro-financial risks are the internal risks that can affect the wider financial system, then the macro-financial risks are those system-wide vulnerabilities that can create a real shock to the wider financial system and therefore increase the likelihood of financial instability.
These risks are related to the interaction between firms, investors and clients. Risks to FinTech companies include the following.
Contagion
Contagion is distress experienced by a single financial institution or sector that can be transmitted to others because of the exposure or relationship between them. Commonalities in the type of business can also lead to mistrust in those institutions and that can also lead to contagion.
If a single, well-known and very well used FinTech platform has a large unexpected loss, it is possible that these losses will be interpreted as happening across the sector.
Pro-Cyclicality
In the well-known activity of excess provisioning of credit by banks during economic upswings, followed by an extreme degree of deleveraging that tends to take place during a downswing. This low pricing during good times and high pricing during bad times is exactly the kind of activity that propagates financial instability.
Interactions between FinTech lending platforms and FinTech borrowing platforms could exhibit larger swings than traditional intermediation of funds which can be further exacerbated by retail investors. FinTech credit companies may have limited incentives to accurately assess credit quality or maintain lending standards and therefore could risk increased pro-cyclicality.
Excess Volatility
The Financial Stability Board put it right when they said: “the financial system can overreact to news”. This overreaction can lead to solvency or liquidity problems that can spiral to the financial system impairing the functioning of credit markets, especially when there is congruity.
The use of FinTech AI and apps to trade in the market can increase market volatility because they make computer-based decisions. In a period of low volatility, a FinTech trader can be more active but as soon as there is some volatility, they can rapidly withdraw from the market. When the market is already stressed, this can exacerbate potential for volatility.
Systemic Importance
If an entity is critical, it may amplify risks. Companies who see themselves as critically important have less competition in the market and are therefore more inclined to take risks where the downside may be limited by the guarantee of public support of a critical service. Predatory pricing could also stifle competition reducing the likelihood of other services stepping in when the entity suffers distress.
This, of course, is still an issue with the traditional financial model but you can predict a scenario whereby a FinTech company earns a monopoly or oligopoly for their convenient and efficient service. This needs to be avoided.
Oh What, Oh What Can a FinTech Do?
This article focuses on the risks of FinTech without weighing against the potential benefits but FinTech companies can also bring several benefits to the economy as a whole. In brief.
- Diversification and decentralisation. In areas such as lending, big data processing and automation of loans have reduced barriers to entry. Distributed ledger technology like blockchain can also reduce concentration in the settlement process.
- Efficiency. Innovations in financial services can lead to greater productivity. Regulation technology or AI chat bots can streamline back-office functions and strengthen business models for institutions as well as facilitate and automate the decision making process.
- Transparency. Increased use of data may have the potential to reduce asymmetries in information. Better data is paving the way for smart contracts that can more accurately target specific risks users wish to manage.
- Access and convenience. The ability to improve access to a range of financial services in regions where there is a large population of people who don’t have access to banks and where the financial market is only in early development. In these areas, likelihood of owning a smartphone is higher than having a bank account and so app-based financial services are a huge benefit.
So let’s not give up just yet, FinTech companies have a lot to bring to this economy, it is simply important for us to recognize what the risks are and try to mitigate these. Regulations can help to do this but the truth is, each FinTech is responsible for their own effect on the economy and their relationships with other companies around them. Each financial institution is also responsible for auditing the FinTechs they get into relationships with.
Open Banking aims to set a precedence for this kind of thinking. For example, they set a framework for APIs being built between FinTech companies and financial institutions so as to educate the sector and reduce the likelihood of an attack when sharing data between services.
The very nature of FinTech’s convenient, online platforms make it easy for a customer to leave and not forgetting that these companies service a plugged-in population who, within a few minutes of their time, can leave an online review.
Therefore, large financial institutions and smaller FinTech companies each require elements the other can provide in order to successfully meet growing consumer demands for greater access to and management of their finances. As a result, the lack of consistent FinTech cybersecurity will be a hindrance for both. As these two sides of the financial services space increasingly partner up, then, cybersecurity – especially application security, cloud security, and automation will have to become top concerns to maintain data protection and meet compliance requirements while responding to the shifting demands of the marketplace.
Share this Post
Write for Us
Apply NowSubscribe to our Blog
GlobalSign Privacy Policy Version 3.1
Updated June 5, 2018
GlobalSign respects your right to privacy. This privacy policy has been developed to inform you about the privacy practices followed by GlobalSign in connection with its websites, products and services. This privacy policy does not apply to GlobalSign services offered by or through our partners, resellers or other third parties, or other third party services or websites, and we encourage you to read the privacy policies of those parties.
This privacy policy will inform you about what data is collected, how we use such data, where data is processed, how you may opt out of your data being used, the security provisions around storing your data and how to correct, update or delete your data.
1. Data Controller
The data controller for personal data collected within the EU is GMO GlobalSign, Ltd., having its registered offices at Springfield House, Sandling Road, Maidstone, Kent, ME14 2LP, United Kingdom. All questions or requests regarding the processing of data may be addressed to: dpo@globalsign.com.
2. Collection of Personal Information
We collect information from you when you (i) place an order for a GlobalSign digital certificate product or other product or service, (ii) scan your servers for digital certificates using our Certificate Inventory Tool (CIT), (iii) apply for access to our managed service platforms, (iv) subscribe to our newsletter, (v) use our online chat service, (vi) download a white paper, (vii) register for a webinar, (viii) respond to a survey, (ix) fill out a form for pre/post sales assistance, (x) open a support ticket, or (xi) your use of social media.
GlobalSign is a Certification Authority and trusted third party. To fulfill requests for digital certificates or other products or services, you may be asked to enter your name, email address, physical address, phone number, credit card information and/or organizational details or other personal information.
- - Contact information such as your name, email address, physical address, and phone number.
- - Relationship information that helps us do business with you, such as the types of products and services that may interest you, contact and product preferences, languages, marketing preferences and demographic data.
- - Transactional information about how you interact with us, including purchases, inquiries, customer account information, billing and credit card information, organizational details, transaction and correspondence history, and information about how you use and interact with our website.
We may develop and acquire additional information about you using third-party (public and private) data sources such as third party databases and government agencies, as well as your browsing and purchasing history in order to process orders for certificates and to improve our services.
GlobalSign treats personal information as confidential, except for the information included in an issued digital certificate. Such information may be verified using third party commercial and government resources, and as such, is deemed to be public information.
3. Purpose of Processing
Your personal data will be used for the purposes specified below:
3.1 To process applications for GlobalSign products and services
Your information is used to provide our products and services and order processing as well as to conduct business transactions such as billing.
3.2 To improve customer service
Your information helps us to more effectively respond to your pre/post sales requests and provide technical support.
3.3 To send renewal notices
The email address you provide for order processing may be used to send you renewal notices for your expiring digital certificate.
3.4 To send service updates
In addition, subject to your consent where required, we may send you new service updates, security updates, related product or service information, and status updates on maintenance windows or service availability.
3.5 To tell you about our products and services
Subject to your consent where required, we may send you periodic company newsletters, information about our products and services that may be of interest to you based on your use of other GlobalSign products and services, your attendance at GlobalSign sponsored marketing events such as webinars, your requests for information about similar products and services, or your sharing of data with social media sites such as LinkedIn or Facebook.
4. Legal Basis for Processing Personal Data
We will process your data for the purpose of performance of our contract with you or the legitimate interest of GlobalSign, which are our usual business activities. In other cases, we will request your consent for the processing of the personal data you may submit.
Your refusal to provide personal data to us for certain products and services may hinder us from fulfilling your order for those products or services. Also, if you deny or withdraw your consent to use personal data or opt out of receiving information about GlobalSign products and services this may result in you not being made aware of renewal notices, periodic company newsletters, new service updates, security updates, related product or service information, and status updates on maintenance windows or service availability. See Section 10 below for how to withdraw your consent.
5. Use of Cookies and web beacons
The GlobalSign Certificate Center (GCC) uses cookies to enable the fulfillment of services. Cookies may be used when you log into the GCC, purchase products or use certain GCC functions.
In addition, like most online businesses, GlobalSign uses cookies and web beacons on our websites and through marketing related emails to gather and analyze some personal data such as the visitor's IP address, browser type, ISP, referring page, operating system, date/time and basic geographical information.
We use cookies and web beacons to compile aggregate data about site traffic and site interaction so that we can gauge the effectiveness of our communications and offer better site experiences and tools in the future. We may contract with third-party service providers to assist us in better understanding our site visitors. These service providers are not permitted to use the information collected on our behalf except to help us conduct and improve our business.
First time visitors may choose to not have any activity monitoring cookies set in their browser. We use an opt-out identification cookie to tag these users as having made this decision. Those cookies that pertain to site performance, experience improvement and marketing are programmed not to execute when an opt-out cookie is present in a visitor's browser. Opt-out cookies persist until a visitor clears their browser cookies, or until their expiration one year after the set date. A visitor is required to opt out again after one year in order to disable any activity monitoring cookies.
More details of GlobalSign's use of cookies can be found on our website at https://www.globalsign.com/en/repository/cookie-policy/
6. Use of application logs for diagnostics or to gather statistical information
Our servers automatically record information ("Application Log Data") created by your use of our services. Application Log Data may include information such as your IP address, browser type, operating system, the referring web page, pages visited, location, your mobile carrier, device and application IDs, search terms, and cookie information. We use this information to diagnose and improve our services. Except as stated in section 8 (Data Retention), we will either delete the Application Log Data or remove any account identifiers, such as your username, full IP address, or email address, after 12 months.
7. Sharing of Information and Transfers of Data
We do not sell or trade your personal information to outside parties.
Within GlobalSign: GlobalSign is a global organization with business processes and technical systems in various countries. As such, we may share information about you within our group company and transfer it to countries in the world where we do business in connection with the uses identified in section 3 above and in accordance with this Privacy Policy. In cases where your personal data is transferred to countries that do not provide an adequate level of protection according to the European Commission ('adequacy decision'), we ensure your data is protected by entering into agreements containing standard contractual clauses approved by the European Commission with each of our group companies. A copy of these agreements may be obtained by contacting us as outlined in section 15 below.
Third Parties: We may also transfer your personal data to trusted third parties and our partners in order to serve purposes that are specified in section 3 above. GlobalSign uses a third party to process credit card payments and provides credit card numbers and identifying financial data directly to the third party credit card processor.
In circumstances where data is shared with such third parties, they are required to comply with confidentiality terms included in our data processing agreements. This prohibits such third parties from selling, trading, using, marketing or otherwise distributing GlobalSign customer data.
As Required by Law: We may also release your information when we believe release is appropriate to comply with the law or protect our rights, property, or safety.
It is our policy to notify customers of requests for their data from law enforcement unless we are prohibited from doing so by statute or court order. Law enforcement officials who believe that notification would jeopardize an investigation should obtain an appropriate court order or other process that specifically precludes member notification, such as an order issued pursuant to 18 U.S.C. §2705(b).
Mergers & Acquisitions: We may also disclose your personal information to third parties who may take over the operation of our site or who may purchase any or all of our assets, including your personal information. We will contact you using the details you provide if there is any change in the person controlling your information.
8. International Transfers
The third parties, subsidiaries and affiliates to which your personal information can be disclosed may be located throughout the world. Therefore, information may be sent to countries having different privacy protection standards than your country of residence. In such cases, we take measures to ensure that your personal information receives an adequate level of protection, which includes the EU Standard Contractual Clauses to protect your personal information.
9. Data retention
The personal information we collect is retained for no longer than necessary to fulfil the stated purposes in section 2 above or for a period specifically required by law or regulation that GlobalSign is obligated to follow.
To meet public CA audit requirements as detailed in the GlobalSign Certification Practice Statement, personal data used to fulfill verification of certain types of digital certificate applications will be retained for a minimum of 10 years depending on the class of product or service and may be retained in either a physical or electronic format. Please refer to the GlobalSign Certification Practice Statement for full details.
After the retention period is over, GlobalSign securely disposes or anonymizes your personal information in order to prevent loss, theft, misuse, or unauthorized access.
10. Opting out; withdrawing consent
If at any time you would like to unsubscribe from receiving future emails, we include unsubscribe instructions at the bottom of each email.
Renewal notices may be cancelled on a per digital certificate basis by logging into your GlobalSign Certificate Center (GCC) account and disabling renewal notices.
Email preferences for CIT related/collected information can be updated and changed within CIT.
If GlobalSign is processing your personal data based on your consent, you may withdraw your consent at any time via the GlobalSign Preference Centre at https://downloads.globalsign.com/acton/media/2674/preference-center-login or by contacting us at one of the addresses shown in section 15 below.
11. Your Rights
You are responsible for providing GlobalSign with true, accurate, current and complete personal information. Also, you are responsible to maintain and promptly update the information to keep it true, accurate, current and complete.
You have the right to access and modify your personal data stored on GlobalSign systems. You can exercise your rights by contacting us in writing. We will require you to provide identification in order to verify the authenticity as the data subject. We will make reasonable efforts to respond to and process your request as required by law.
To the extent of applicable law, you may have the right to request erasure of your personal information, restriction of processing as it applies to you, object to processing and the right to data portability. You may also have the right to lodge a complaint with a supervisory authority.
If you provide any information that is untrue, inaccurate, not current or incomplete, or if we have reasonable grounds to suspect that such information is untrue, inaccurate, not current or incomplete, we have the right to suspend or terminate your account and refuse any and all current or future services.
12. How we protect your information
We implement a variety of security measures to maintain the safety of your personal information when you place an order or enter, submit, or access your personal information. All supplied sensitive/credit information is transmitted via Secure Socket Layer (SSL).
After a transaction, your transaction-related information will be kept on file to meet audit requirements and facilitate renewals. We do not retain any credit card details.
13. Relevant laws
GlobalSign commits itself to protect the personal information submitted by applicants and subscribers for its public certification services. GlobalSign declares to fully respect all rights established and laid out in European Union and Member States' laws and regulations:
- - European Directive 95/46 on the protection of individuals with regard to the processing of personal data and on the free movement of such data and as replaced by Regulation EU 2016/679 on the protection of natural persons with regard to the processing of personal data and on the free movement of such data (the EU General Data Protection Regulation); and
- - Provisions of the GlobalSign CPS.
14. Changes to our Privacy Policy
If we make material changes to our privacy policy, we will inform customers by emailing a notice of the availability of a new version with a link to the new version.
15. Contact Us
If you have any inquires, or questions regarding our privacy policy, please contact us at:
- We use the data you submit only for purposes identified in section 3 of this privacy policy.
- You have the right to review your personal data that GlobalSign holds and check it for accuracy.
- You have the right to correct data in the case that errors may be found in our records.
- You have the right to request that any of your personal data be erased. i.e. right to be forgotten.
- You have the right to obtain and reuse use your personal data for your own purposes
- You have the right to request that GlobalSign restrict the processing of your personal data under certain circumstances.
- You have the right to object to our processing of your personal data.
14. Changes to our Privacy Policy
If we make material changes to our privacy policy, we will inform customers by emailing a notice of the availability of a new version with a link to the new version.
15. Contact Us
If you have any inquires, or questions regarding our privacy policy, please contact us at:
https://support.globalsign.com/
https://www.globalsign.com/en/company/contact/support/
https://jp.globalsign.com/support/
or
Deputy Data Protection Officer
GMO GlobalSign, Ltd.
Springfield House Sandling Road
Maidstone, Kent ME 14 2LP
United Kingdom
dpo@globalsign.com
16. Our Office Locations
GMO GlobalSign K.K., Tokyo, Japan
GMO GlobalSign Ltd., Maidstone, Kent, UK
GMO GlobalSign N/V, Leuven, Belgium
GMO GlobalSign, Inc., Portsmouth, NH, USA
GMO GlobalSign Russia LLC , Moskva, Russia
GMO GlobalSign Pte. Ltd, Anson, Singapore
GMO GlobalSign Certificate Services Pvt. Ltd., Delhi, India
GlobalSign China Co., Ltd., Shanghai, China
GMO GlobalSign Inc., Manila, Philippines
GMO GlobalSign FZ-LLC, Dubai, UAEYou might enjoy:
Addressing Cybersecurity in FinTech Partnerships
What Is Paperless Banking?